Easy No Bake Sugar Free Low Carb Keto Grasshopper Pie

This decadent, creamy Keto Grasshopper Mousse Pie is a no bake dessert made sugar free, low carb, gluten free, keto and nut free as well! Just 3 g net carbs per serving!

What is a Grasshopper Pie?

A Grasshopper is a sweet, mint flavored after dinner drink with its green color coming from creme de menthe.

It was created in 1918 in the French Quarter of Louisiana. While this something I have never drank or want to drink, the green color and the mint flavor work perfectly for celebrating St. Patrick’s Day with a family or even Easter with the fun, light green color!

The secret ingredient for this lovely special treat for St.Patrick’s day, is using a small amount of avocado to achieve that natural green color. You won’t notice any flavor of avocado because the peppermint extract and peppermint stevia will overcome that avocado taste. 

St. Patrick’s Day was never a holiday we’d celebrate when I was growing up,  in my Italian household. My mom never made green food and I never ate Corned Beef and Cabbage until I met my husband and married. But I must be honest, I love all the traditional holiday menu items and enjoy carrying on traditions for my kids!

My children see and hear about all things green during this time of year so I feel obligated as a momma to provide them some of these traditional favorites during this time of year.

Carbs in Grasshopper Pie Recipe

According to Cronometer, the app I use daily for my keto diet, says that one piece of a 9 inch pie with chocolate crust has 47.3 g total carbs and 432 calories.

That amount of carbs is too high if you’re on a keto diet. It may work for those on a low carb diet, but if you’re watching your sugar intake because you’re diabetic or have sugar cravings, this pie has 32 grams of sugar. 

​Carbs in Keto Grasshopper Pie

Our healthier version of a traditional Grasshopper pie, has just 3 grams net carbs and 5 grams total carbs. When your sweet tooth is calling, the best thing about our keto grasshopper pie is that it won’t spike your blood sugar. 

All remaining nutritional information is below in the recipe card, bottom of this post. 

Healthy Grasshopper Pie

But this dessert has been their number 1 favorite by far! The creamy filling is creamy mint mousse has always been their favorite, just like me. So adding some mint and some green color made this a win win for the whole family to celebrate St.Patty’s day!

Drizzle on a little more Chocolate sauce right before serving for extra deliciousness!

Super light texture, but totally satisfying in every bite.

It may be hard to resist one serving so it’s best if you enjoy this for a special occasion, when you can share with others!

Left overs can be dangerous, you’ve been warned!

Traditional Chocolate Cookie Crust

You can use any pie crust you like. The nutrition info includes my own no bake crust recipe and I think chocolate is the favorite for this type of pie.

But I’ve got others if you’re not into the no bake chocolate crust. 

All my crusts are nut free since my youngest has a tree nut allergy. 

This is a baked Chocolate pie crust, or try my Easy Keto Pie Crust or the crust from this No Bake frozen Strawberry Pie.

Can I change the peppermint stevia?

If you don’t have peppermint stevia it’s not the end of the world but it adds an extra punch to that mint flavor. You can use any sweetener you enjoy, I would say just 1/2 cup.

Since this is a no bake pie, you can truly use any low carb sweetener you like and taste as you go along. I would not recommend any low carb sweetener that is granulated for this creamy mousse pie.

For example low carb erythritol,  because this is a no bake pie and therefore the granulated sweetener will not incorporate well into the pie filling. It would leave you with a grainy texture in my experience and humble opinion. I’d recommend a low carb powdered sweetener or just use liquid sweeteners like stevia or monk fruit. 

Here’s my Ultimate Low Carb Sweetener Guide to help you decide how much of another sugar substitute to use instead of the ones I used in the whole pie. 

Can I replace avocado? 

If you have an allergy to avocado and can’t use it, replace it with more cream cheese in the same amount and then use some natural food coloring to achieve the light green color. 

Can I make this a Paleo Grasshopper Pie?

If you want to make this grasshopper pie dairy free you will need to replace the cream cheese with a vegan cream cheese and replace the heavy cream with canned coconut milk or coconut cream, just the white part of the can, which is nice and thick. 

​Can I use fresh mint leaves? 

If you want to use real mint leaves instead of mint extract, you could do that. I’d recommend processing it with a small amount of water in a blender to make more of a puree that can easily be mixed in with the cream cheese and heavy whipping cream.

More Sugar Free Minty Desserts: